When shopping for a vehicle, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is whether to buy a new or used car. Both options have their pros and cons, and the right choice depends on your budget, preferences, and priorities. Let’s break down the pros and cons of buying a new vs. used car to help you decide what’s best for you!
A new car comes equipped with the latest in safety, entertainment, and performance technology. Features like adaptive cruise control, lane assist, and the most up-to-date infotainment systems are standard in most new models.
New vehicles come with full manufacturer warranties, often covering repairs for three to five years. This peace of mind can be a huge benefit, as you won’t need to worry about unexpected repair costs during that period.
Read More: Guide to Financing a Toyota in Ontario
When you buy new, you can often choose the exact model, color, features, and trims you want, especially if you place a factory order. This customization allows you to drive away in a vehicle that perfectly matches your needs and preferences.
With a new vehicle, there’s no need to worry about previous owners, accidents, or maintenance issues. Everything is in pristine condition, which lowers the risk of unexpected problems down the road.
Read More: Buying Your First New Car
New cars come with a higher price. If you’re on a tight budget, the cost of a new vehicle may be prohibitive, especially if you opt for higher-end models with extra features.
New cars start to lose their value the moment you drive them off the lot, typically depreciating by 20-30% in the first year alone. If you plan to sell or trade-in your car within a few years, this depreciation could be a disadvantage.
One of the most significant advantages of buying a used vehicle is the lower price. A used car is often much more affordable than a new one, allowing you to stretch your budget further and potentially afford a better make or model.
Read More: 9 Car Dealer Fees to Never Pay
While new cars depreciate quickly, used vehicles have already gone through the sharpest depreciation period. This means the car you buy won’t lose its value as dramatically as a new one would.
Since used cars generally have a lower value than new cars, insurance premiums tend to be cheaper. This can save you money on a month-to-month basis.
Read More: Used Car Prices
While some used cars, especially Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) vehicles, come with warranties, these are typically shorter or more limited than those for new cars. If the vehicle is not certified, you may face higher repair costs once the warranty expires. Without a comprehensive warranty, you might be responsible for more out-of-pocket expenses in the event of a breakdown or malfunction.
Depending on the car’s age and mileage, s may require more frequent repairs or maintenance. Older cars, in particular, could have parts that are closer to the end of their useful life, which might lead to unexpected repairs. However, many used cars undergo safety checks and reconditioning before being sold, meaning any known issues are typically addressed before you drive the car off the lot.
Read More: Lease a Car
When buying used, you may have to compromise on the vehicle’s features, color, or condition. You’ll be limited to the options available at the dealership or from private sellers, and the car may not perfectly match your preferences. If you’re looking for a very specific set of features or a particular color, the selection might be smaller compared to buying new.
Read More: Used Car Checklist
Used vehicles can sometimes come with higher interest rates on financing compared to new cars. Lenders often consider used cars to be riskier investments since they’re more prone to wear and tear and may not have the same resale value as a new car. As a result, financing a used car may increase your monthly payments.
Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) vehicles are pre-owned cars that have undergone a detailed inspection and reconditioning process to meet strict standards set by the manufacturer or dealership. These vehicles typically come with an extended warranty, which provides peace of mind and helps reduce the risk of unexpected repair costs.
When you choose a CPO vehicle, you can trust that it has been carefully inspected for quality, and any necessary repairs or replacements have been made to restore the car to its best possible condition. This gives you the reliability of a new car, without the higher price tag.
Additionally, CPO vehicles often come with a warranty that covers many of the car's major components, offering further assurance that you’re making a smart investment. These warranties are typically more comprehensive than those available with standard used cars, and in many cases, include benefits like roadside assistance and vehicle history reports.
Buying a CPO vehicle offers the best of both worlds— a reliable used car at a lower price than a new one, with the added peace of mind that comes from knowing it’s been thoroughly inspected and certified by experts.
Read More: Certified Used Cars
Consider buying a new car if:
Consider buying a used car if:
Read More: 7 Smart Tips for the Cheapest Car Insurance
When deciding should I buy a new car or used car, emotions can play a large role. Some buyers are drawn to the idea of owning a brand-new car because of the "new car smell" and the pride that comes with a fresh purchase. The sense of owning something untouched and perfect can be appealing, especially if you value the experience of a brand-new vehicle. On the other hand, some buyers prefer the new vs second hand car route because of the cost savings, often finding the decision to go with a second hand car vs new car a smarter financial choice.
When debating between buying new vs used car, it’s easy to assume that a brand-new vehicle will be free from maintenance concerns for years. While it’s true that new cars are typically covered by warranties for major repairs, this doesn't mean they’re maintenance-free. Even new cars require regular upkeep to keep running smoothly and maintain their longevity.
In the early years, routine tasks like oil changes, tire rotations, brake checks, and air filter replacements are part of the ownership experience, though these costs are usually modest. While the warranty covers major repairs, it won't take care of these smaller, yet necessary, services. These preventive measures are essential to keep your car operating efficiently, ensuring that its performance remains optimal and avoiding more significant issues down the road.
As the years go by, however, wear and tear will inevitably set in. Tires will eventually need replacing, brake pads will wear out, and other components will need attention. The cost of maintaining a new car over time can gradually increase as its parts begin to age and require repair or replacement. While this is a normal part of owning any vehicle, it's worth considering that with a new car, the upfront costs and occasional services can feel more manageable compared to the potential ongoing repairs and unpredictable maintenance needs of an older, used vehicle.
For many, this predictability and the relative ease of handling a new car’s maintenance can feel like a reassuring option when compared to the potential hassle of dealing with an older car. Used vehicles, especially those with higher mileage or a less predictable service history, may require more frequent, and sometimes costly, repairs. The decision to buy new can thus offer a sense of security that the car is still under warranty and has fewer hidden surprises lurking under the hood.
Ultimately, while new cars still need regular attention, their predictability and warranty coverage can offer a level of peace of mind that older vehicles may not be able to provide.
Read More: Used Car Under $20,000 CAD
When asking yourself should I buy a new or used vehicle, you might also want to consider your current car’s trade-in value. If you’re currently driving a vehicle and are planning to purchase a new or used car, trading in your old car can offset the cost. In fact, if you're wondering is it better to buy a new or used car, factoring in your trade-in could make buying new much more affordable than you think.
If you’re looking at the new vs used car purchase decision, remember that trade-in offers can sometimes be higher for new vehicles due to their higher market value. However, if you’re looking at new car vs used car, trading in your old vehicle for a used one could still leave you with significant savings.
Ultimately, the decision between new vs used vehicle comes down to your personal priorities. If you’re seeking the advantages of buying a new car, you may want the latest features, a full warranty, and the security of knowing your vehicle is in perfect condition. On the other hand, if you’re focused on value and want to avoid the sharp depreciation of a new car, buying new car vs used car could lead you to a second hand car vs new car situation, where you get a reliable vehicle for less money.
When considering buying a new car vs used car, think about your long-term plans, budget, and the features that matter most to you. Whether you choose to buy new or used car, make sure to weigh all factors carefully to make the right decision.
At CarRookie, our team of auto experts is dedicated to helping you find your dream car. We connect you with top-rated sales agents who guide you through the entire process, ensuring a smooth, stress-free, and enjoyable buying experience. Whether you're leaning toward a new or used vehicle, we’re here to make your journey toward the perfect car hassle-free.
Canadian Used Car Market Trends 2025: Wholesale Prices Dip Slightly in Early July The Canadian used car market trends in 2025 continue
Elon Musk Faces Growing Threat Amidst Canada’s EV Mandate Controversy OTTAWA — The future of Canada’s electric vehicle (EV) policy, specifically
