Top 10 Fuel Economy Used Cars in Toronto

September 2, 2025
best fuel economy used cars

When it comes to finding the best fuel economy used cars, Toronto drivers know that good gas mileage can make all the difference. With the city’s traffic and long commutes, owning a car that gets great fuel efficiency is not just smart—it’s essential. Whether you're looking for a compact sedan, a hybrid, or a spacious hatchback, there are plenty of options that offer best gas mileage used cars for every budget and lifestyle.

In this article, we’ll look at some of the most fuel-efficient used cars available in the market today. These cars offer outstanding MPG (miles per gallon) and will help you save money at the pump without compromising on performance.

Best Fuel Economy Used Cars for Toronto Drivers

1. Toyota Prius (Hybrid)

MPG: 50+ city / 50+ highway

The Toyota Prius stands out as one of the best fuel economy used cars available. As a hybrid, it combines an electric motor with a gasoline engine, offering exceptional fuel efficiency. Whether you're navigating Toronto’s busy streets or heading out of town, the Prius offers most fuel-efficient second-hand cars benefits and saves you significant money on gas.

2. Honda Civic (Sedan)

MPG: 32 city / 42 highway

The Honda Civic is a long-time favorite among Toronto drivers. Known for its reliability and great fuel economy, it continues to be one of the best used cars with best gas mileage. With plenty of space, low maintenance costs, and excellent fuel efficiency, it’s a solid choice for anyone seeking used cars with good mpg.

3. Hyundai Elantra

MPG: 33 city / 41 highway

Looking for most fuel-efficient second-hand cars that won’t break the bank? The Hyundai Elantra delivers great mileage at a budget-friendly price. Offering a smooth ride and a comfortable interior, it’s an excellent choice for commuters in Toronto who want to save on gas without sacrificing comfort.

4. Mazda3

MPG: 28 city / 37 highway

The Mazda3 is a used car with good gas mileage that’s also fun to drive. It combines stylish design with a reputation for reliability, making it one of the best mpg vehicles used. If you're looking for a compact car with great fuel efficiency and a bit of personality, the Mazda3 is a great option.

5. Ford Fiesta

MPG: 27 city / 37 highway

Small but mighty, the Ford Fiesta is a fuel-efficient used car that’s perfect for Toronto’s tight streets and busy roads. With its compact size and low fuel consumption, it offers one of the best mpg used cars for those seeking a budget-friendly option that doesn’t compromise on performance.

6. Chevrolet Cruze

MPG: 30 city / 40 highway

The Chevrolet Cruze is an ideal choice for those looking for a used car with good mpg without spending too much on a new car. It delivers excellent gas mileage, particularly on the highway, and provides a comfortable ride with plenty of features.

7. Nissan Versa

MPG: 27 city / 36 highway

The Nissan Versa is one of the best fuel-efficient second-hand cars for anyone looking for a no-fuss, budget-friendly option. While it might not have all the bells and whistles, it offers decent fuel economy and is great for daily driving around Toronto.

8. Honda Insight (Hybrid)

MPG: 40 city / 44 highway

The Honda Insight is another hybrid that deserves a spot on the list of best used fuel-efficient cars. With impressive mileage, low maintenance costs, and a reputation for longevity, it’s a smart choice for drivers who want the benefits of a hybrid without the high price tag of a new model.

9. Toyota Corolla

MPG: 30 city / 38 highway

The Toyota Corolla is a fuel-efficient used car that’s known for its reliability and longevity. It continues to be one of the most fuel-efficient used cars for drivers looking to minimize their fuel expenses while enjoying a smooth, reliable ride.

10. Kia Soul

MPG: 24 city / 30 highway

The Kia Soul may not have the highest fuel efficiency compared to other cars on this list, but it still offers decent MPG for a small crossover. If you're after a fun-to-drive car with good fuel economy and a unique design, the Kia Soul is one of the best used cars with good gas mileage for drivers in Toronto.

Why Fuel Economy Matters for Toronto Drivers

In a bustling city like Toronto, fuel-efficient cars help you save money over time. With gas prices fluctuating, opting for the best fuel economy used cars means you’ll spend less at the pump. Whether you're commuting to work or heading to the suburbs, having a car that offers great MPG can significantly reduce your overall driving costs.

Where to Find the Best Fuel-Efficient Used Cars in Toronto

If you're searching for the best used cars with good gas mileage, consider checking out CarRookie, a trusted car dealership in Toronto. CarRookie specializes in helping customers find the best fuel economy used cars, even if they have poor credit. The dealership connects buyers with experienced agents who will work with you to find a fuel-efficient vehicle that fits your budget.

FAQs

What are the most fuel-efficient used cars for Toronto’s busy traffic?

The Toyota Prius and Honda Civic are excellent choices for Toronto’s heavy traffic, as they offer great gas mileage and are easy to handle in the city.

Can I find a best mpg vehicle used under $10,000 in Toronto?

Yes! Cars like the Hyundai Elantra, Ford Fiesta, and Nissan Versa are often available for under $10,000 and offer solid MPG for city and highway driving.

Are hybrid cars more fuel-efficient than regular gas-powered cars?

Yes, hybrid cars like the Toyota Prius and Honda Insight typically offer better MPG because they combine an electric motor with a gasoline engine, using less fuel.

How much can I save annually by choosing a used car with great fuel efficiency?

If you drive frequently in Toronto, a fuel-efficient used car like the Toyota Prius or Honda Civic could save you hundreds, or even over $1,000, annually on gas.

Do all used cars with good MPG also have low maintenance costs?

While cars with great MPG, like the Toyota Corolla and Honda Civic, tend to have lower maintenance costs, it’s always a good idea to check the car’s maintenance history before purchasing a used vehicle.

Finding the best fuel economy used cars doesn’t have to be a challenge. With so many great options available in Toronto, you can drive a car that offers great mileage and value. For assistance with finding your perfect vehicle, visit CarRookie, where expert agents can help you secure a fuel-efficient used car that suits your needs and budget—even if you have poor credit.

CarRookie